Nairobi – Five Court of Appeal judges have filed a defamation suit against Captain Kung’u Muigai, seeking damages, a public apology, and an order barring him from making further claims after he alleged on social media that they had been bribed to rule against him.
The plaintiffs, Justices Milton Asike-Makhandia, Kathurima M’Inoti, Sankale Ole Kantai, Francis Tuiyott, and John Mativo, filed the case on August 6, 2026.
The suit relates to statements Muigai published on September 8 and 10, 2025, following the judges’ May 24, 2024 ruling that dismissed his application to reopen an earlier decision in a long-running loan recovery dispute with KCB Bank.
Background to the KCB loan dispute
The underlying case traces its origins to 1989, when KCB advanced Benjoh Amalgamated Ltd a loan of KSh 18.6 million to fund a flower export business under the Rural Projects Enterprise Programme, a scheme backed by the United States Agency for International Development (USAID).
The facility was secured against two properties, LR No. 12411/1 and LR No. 12411/2, with Muiri Coffee Estate Ltd providing additional security through a charge over LR No. 10075 in Kiambu County.
Muigai, who describes himself as a director and shareholder of both Benjoh and Muiri Coffee Estate Ltd, maintains that a consent order dated May 4, 1992, which allowed KCB to sell the charged properties after the borrower defaulted, was never formally recorded. The five judges dismissed his bid to revisit that question.
Shortly after the ruling, online posts emerged alleging that the bench’s decision was connected to a payment of KSh 325 million (USD 2.5 million).
Muigai pushes for JSC inquiry
Muigai, a nephew of Kenya’s founding President Jomo Kenyatta and a cousin of former President Uhuru Kenyatta, denies that his posts were defamatory and has called on the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) to investigate the judges’ conduct rather than allow the matter to proceed as a civil defamation claim.
His advocate, Nelson Havi, argued in court that a defamation suit was not the appropriate avenue for the judges to respond to a bribery complaint already lodged with the JSC.
“An action in defamation is not the forum for the plaintiffs to defend themselves on a complaint of bribery lodged with the JSC, which complaint has not been responded to by them, and which complaint has further, not been investigated and determined by the JSC,”Havi said, asking for the case to be dismissed.
Havi further alleged that rather than table the disputed consent order or address the bribery complaint, the Judiciary and the JSC had instead moved to shield the judges from scrutiny.
“Instead of tabling the alleged consent made on May 4, 1992, in Hccc No. 1219 of 1992 or investigating the complaint of bribery made against the plaintiffs by the defendant, the Judiciary and the Judicial Service Commission embarked on an elaborate cover-up exercise, and defence of the plaintiffs,” Havi added.
The case was pending before the court as of Saturday, November 21.
