By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Newsunplug KenyaNewsunplug KenyaNewsunplug Kenya
  • News
    • Metro
    • Politics
    • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Spotify
Reading: How China firm shortchanged taxpayers on Sh21.5bn city road
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Newsunplug KenyaNewsunplug Kenya
Font ResizerAa
  • News
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Spotify
  • News
    • Metro
    • Politics
    • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Spotify
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© 2022 Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
Newsunplug Kenya > Blog > Business > How China firm shortchanged taxpayers on Sh21.5bn city road
Business

How China firm shortchanged taxpayers on Sh21.5bn city road

hallanaija
Last updated: August 29, 2023 5:52 am
hallanaija 2 years ago
Share
road
Kabete Interchange. PHOTO | COURTESY | MINISTRY OF ROADS AND TRANSPORT
SHARE

The Chinese contractor who built the Sh21.5 billion Nairobi Western Bypass omitted six interchanges and other critical infrastructure that were approved in the initial road design, denying taxpayers value for money, the Auditor-General has said.

Auditor-General Nancy Gathungu said that when the contractor, China Road and Bridge Corporation (CRBC), bid and won the tender for the construction of the project at a total cost of $171 million dollars, the project had at least six interchanges at major shopping centres along the highway.

The interchanges—which are more complex junctions—were aimed at providing convenience for the large population centres along the road to ease driving and commuting pain.

But the Auditor-General has found that the interchanges were not on the ground as presented in the approved plan for the project, in the latest revelation of how contractors and State officials collude to cheat taxpayers on major projects.

“The information…indicated that there were six interchanges to be implemented at six shopping centres along the road, all of which are evidently not done,” Ms Gathungu says in an audit of the project for the Fiscal Year ending June 30, 2022.

According to the initial plan, the highway, built under the President Uhuru Kenyatta administration, was to connect the Southern Bypass of Nairobi City, interlinked with the Nairobi–Malaba Road with a full cloverleaf interchange at the intersection.

READ MORE  Saccos using loans to pay dividends are cautioned by Oparanya.

At dirt (Kwa Magu) the contractor was then supposed to build the first diamond interchange, which would allow two directions of traffic to temporarily cross to the left side of the road.

The second diamond interchange was to be built four kilometres from the dirt one at Wangige.

Crossing Kihara-Gacii-Karura Road, some 3.01 kilometres from the second interchange, would be yet another diamond-shaped interchange at Kihara.

Not far from Kihara, and crossing the Limuru Road, CRBC was to build a Cloverleaf interchange at Ndenderu.

This more sophisticated interchange would allow the two highways to cross without the need for any traffic to be stopped by traffic lights.

This would be followed by a simple interchange at Rumingi. The last one, as the road connected to the starting point of the Northern Bypass, would be at Ruaka Town.

In its response, the Kenya National Highways Authority (KeNHA), the procuring entity, noted that the switch to cheaper modifications was due largely to the high cost of acquiring land for the interchanges.

road
Kabete Interchange. PHOTO | COURTESY | MINISTRY OF ROADS AND TRANSPORT

“Omission of the first interchange was informed by the necessity to contain the cost of the project within the contractual sum, and the savings made would be channelled to cover the cost of an additional 1.384 metres of reinforced earth retaining walls and part of the 725m additional gravity retaining walls along the alignment,” said KeNHA.

READ MORE  Safaricom extends 5G coverage to 21 counties

The high cost of acquiring land was also cited as the main reason the other interchanges were not delivered as initially designed.

Ms Gathungu was not satisfied with the road agency’s explanation giving the project a qualified opinion, which means they contained material misstatements or omissions in some cases.

The top accountant in her audit report to the National Assembly said KeNHA did not explain the circumstances under which the contracting for the project was done before acquiring and securing the rights of way for the construction.

“Further, no explanation was provided detailing the circumstances under which the specifications of the project were changed with the aim of not exceeding the contract sum, considering that the contractor bid and won the tender for construction of the project at the contract sum of $170,998,693.24 (Sh24.8 billion) which included the cost of all the components which were removed from the scope.”

As a result, the auditor noted that it was not possible to confirm that the full scope of the project was implemented as envisaged in the original design of the project.

READ MORE  Sh540bn bad loans pile blots bank profits

“Further, it was not possible to confirm that the road was constructed to quality and cost-effectiveness, resulting in value for money to the beneficiaries of the project,” she added.

The damning verdict is likely to turn the spotlight on the intermittent contract variations that have often been made on road projects under the guise of cutting costs.

For example, the entire 13km stretch of Nairobi’s Outering Road initially did not have a footbridge yet 11 had been planned for in the design, leading to a public outcry over accidents. Some footbridges were eventually provided.

Outering Road does not also have provision for matatu stages, although this is the most popular form of public transport in Nairobi.

This has meant that matatus pick up and drop passengers on the road. The same script was repeated during the construction of Ngong Road.

You Might Also Like

State moves to defuse tiff in cooking oil imports bid

KICC earned Sh1.07 billion revenue in 6 months CS Mutua Says

Debt payments surpass State running expenses

Indonesia, Kenya push to strengthen bilateral ties

Sixth round of US-Kenya trade discussions will be open to the public.

Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
Previous Article Kilimani MCA Moses Ogeto blasts media for ‘exposing’ Sakaja
Next Article Twiga foods Twiga tycoon Peter Njonjo transfers Ruto’s 20,000-acre deal to private company
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

about us

We influence 20 million users and is the number one business and technology news network on the planet.

Recent Posts

  • FULL analysis of VAR interventions in La Liga this season reveals unending mistakes from Spanish referees
  • Kitale: 19-year-old boy killed for allowing cows to graze in maize farm
  • Barcelona fan delivers strong argument on why Hansi Flick will not last at Barca
  • Chaos in Nandi as police unleash teargas during MP Salasya’s rally
  • 21-year-old woman attacked, raped and left for dead in Nyandarua

Recent Comments

No comments to show.
Newsunplug KenyaNewsunplug Kenya
© Newsunplug Kenya. All Rights Reserved.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?